Lab Meeting Purpose
Lab meeting is designed to give Weecology members opportunities to gain and practice skills, obtain feedback, and interact with the broader research group.
Lab Meeting Organization
To make lab meeting a positive and useful experience for everyone, we have defined a series of lab meeting types with associated guidelines on how the leader should prepare and what role the group should play during lab meeting. Each semester we will assess the overall needs of the group and assign lab meeting types to particular dates. Lab members can select and trade dates but, because we have a plan for the order of slots, lab meeting types should not be moved from their assigned dates without approval from Ethan and Morgan.
Lab Meeting Types (Alphabetical)
A list of some possible lab meeting types including their purpose, format, the responsbilities of the person leading the lab meeting and the responsibilities of the group is listed below.
There is also a flowchart version to help you decide what format works best for you.
Lightening Talk Sessions
- Purpose: To communicate within the lab about current research projects to encourage interactions and collaborations related to shared interests.
- Format: All or some subset of the lab will give 5-minute talk following Ignite talk style.
- Leader Responsibilities: Every speaker is expected to give a 5 minute talk (and no longer!) on one of their projects that abides by the ESA Inspire guidelines.
- Group Duties: Enjoy and think about what projects have in common and what skills discussed in the talks might be useful for other projects in the lab.
- Purpose: To promote skill and information transfer within the group and provide opportunities to gain teaching experience in-house.
- Format: A 45 minute lesson on any topic of general interest to the group.
- Leader Responsibilities: Good teaching takes advance planning. Take time to think about the current knowledge levels within the group and design a lesson plan that will convey your information/skills effectively. Try to avoid unnecessary jargon as it often creates more barriers to learning than it helps overcome. Determine an appropriate amount of material for 45 minutes - it’s about how much people learn, not about how much you present, and less is often better. It is recommended that the leader practice their lesson privately before delivering it to the group. If the group needs to do any advanced preparation, make sure to communicate this well in advance (i.e. not the day of the lab meeting).
- Group Duties: Ask questions if confused. This serves the dual purpose of helping group members learn (others are probably also confused) and helps the leader understand where there are issues with their lesson plan that can be improved in the future.
- Purpose: To get feedback on the organization, flow, and clarity of a talk that is going to be presented for a conference, job seminar, defense, etc. Talks should be happening for a specific purpose in the not too distant future.
- Format: A formal presentation matching the format for the talk to be given.
- Leader Responsibilities: The talk should be a complete draft following the format for the planned presentation. To allow feedback on understandibility, engagement, and flow, the talk should be as complete as possible and ideally avoid ‘placeholder’ slides and areas where the leader has to describe what they are planning to say rather than saying it.
- Group Duties: The presenter is looking to improve their talk, so feedback should be focused on improving the presentation for audience comprehension (i.e., How can the slides be improved?, Does the order of idea presentation have a logical flow?, etc). If you have scientific critiques and or suggestions for new analyses, please hold these comments until after lab meeting to avoid distracting from the goal of this session.
- Purpose: To communicate to the lab the overall trajectory of one’s research and get feedback from the lab on possible questions, alternatives, future work. This would be a hybrid of the communicative aspects of the Lightning Talk (but more in-depth) and the Problem-Solving Session (but less focused on a specific problem).
- Format: A presentation that begins with the general questions in the field and any relevant previous work done by the leader, the status of current projects, and future planned projects and approaches. Think of this more as a narrative with past, present, and future; rather than a scientific presentation suitable for a seminar or conference.
- Leader Responsibilities: Communicate to the group the overall goals of your research, and be specific about what sections you’d like feedback on or discussion of. Are you looking for input on alternative methods or data to answer your research questions, feedback about the feasibility and scope of proposed work, suggestions for readings or courses, etc?
- Group Duties: Provide specific and actionable feedback on topics as indicated by the leader. The focus is on the research questions and results, not the presentation, so the style of the presentation is not the focus. Remember that the goal of a research update will focus on in-progress and future work; providing guidance in the form of questions and constructive advice is important.
- Purpose: To get feedback from the lab to address issues that are limiting progress. This could be getting feedback on statistical approaches, data collection issues, interpretation of results, computational challenges, or other activities. This is your chance to leverage the lab’s collective knowledge to address challenges you are facing.
- Format: A presentation that presents a single focal issue that the leader needs feedback on. The presentation should be focused and no longer than 15 minutes (5 minutes of background, 5 minutes explaining the problem, 1-3 explicit questions - i.e., not ‘what do you think?’ - that you are asking the group).
- Leader Responsibilities: Communicate to the group a specific issue that the leader needs help with. This requires enough background and context for the group to understand both what the leader wants from the group and for the group to understand the scope of the problem at hand. The presentation does not need to be polished but it should be polished enough to not to be distracting. Be prepared to engage the group positively through question and answer.
- Group Duties: Provide focused feedback intended to help address the problem posed by the leader. The focus is on the problem, not the presentation, so the style of the presentation is not the focus. Remember that the goal of a problem solving sessions will typically focus on in-progress work and that providing help in positive, forward looking, ways is important.
Research Process Discussions
- Purpose: To provide an opportunity for the group to informally discuss issues related to ’the job of science’ (i.e. career planning, grants, publishing, mentoring, etc).
- Format: Open discussions of general topics, often with a focus on Questions & Answer interactions with Ethan & Morgan supplemented by additional perspectives from the broader group. These will typically be ’led’ by Morgan and Ethan with topics selected based on the general needs of the group.
- Leader Responsibilities: Make sure the lab is notified in advance of lab meeting so the group can come prepared with questions.
- Group Duties: Group members should think beforehand about their questions, issues, concerns about the topic and come prepared to actively engage to make sure they get what they need out of the discussion. While Ethan and Morgan will pick topics, suggestions are always welcome at the bottom of the semester’s lab meeting page and we may poll to get the groups perspective on what they want to discuss most.
- Purpose: To obtain help from the group to accomplish a task (i.e. data entry, software testing).
- Format: A one hour focused period of work with tasks that can be accomplished during that hour.
- Leader Responsibilities: Leaders need to be organized beforehand with a plan for precisely what they want to accomplish, how they will organize the group to do this, and how much information needs to be conveyed to the group about what they are doing so they can do their tasks effectively and efficiently. The more organized the leader is, the more effective a sprint will be and the more positive the experience will be for everyone.
- Group Duties: The group in this context is working to help the leader attain their goal. Put aside other work for this period and focus on the task at hand. Ask questions if you are unclear on what is expected or if you encounter a situation not covered by the leader in the sprint briefing.
- Purpose: To provide more structure training activities related to designing and presenting a good talk.
- Format: Variable.
- Leader Responsibilities: To design material/activities that will help the group with structuring and designing talks and give them opportunities to practice.
- Group Duties: Focus on talk structure and design and not details of the scientific content.
Team Building Activities
- Purpose: Activities to help break down barriers in the group and promote positive interactions.
- Format: Variable.
- Leader Responsibilities: These activities will be organized by Ethan or Morgan, but all weecologists are welcome to make suggestions for group activities.
- Group Duties: Try to interact with members of the lab that you do not regularly interact with.